E-Shot Media Practical guides to email newsletters

Write

Writing subject lines and preheaders that get read

How the inbox shows your email, what makes a subject line work, and how to use the preheader instead of wasting it.

Updated 6 min read

Before anyone reads a word of your newsletter, they see three things in their inbox: who it's from, the subject line and a short line of preview text. On that basis alone they decide whether to open it now, leave it for later, delete it or mark it as spam. That's a lot of weight for perhaps fifteen words.

Good subject lines are not about tricks. They're about telling the right reader, clearly and quickly, why this email is worth their time. This guide covers how the inbox displays your email, what tends to work, what to avoid, and how to make the preheader pull its weight instead of wasting it.

How the inbox shows your email

Most email apps show a message in a list with three parts, though the layout varies:

  • The sender name, which is the "from" name you set in your email software.
  • The subject line.
  • The preheader (also called preview text or a snippet): the first bit of text the app finds in the email, or text you have set specifically for this purpose.
Hartley Garden CentreWhat to sow in March (and what to wait on)Plus: compost is back in stock, and our Easter opening hours.
Ashgrove Running ClubSunday's route has changedRoadworks on Mill Lane: we're starting from the car park instead. Map inside.
NewsletterMarch NewsletterView this email in your browser

The third row shows what goes wrong: a generic sender, a subject that says nothing, and a preheader wasted on a boilerplate link. The first two tell you exactly what you'll get.

Space is limited. On a phone, many apps show only the first 30 to 40 characters of a subject before cutting it off, and the exact amount depends on the app, the screen and the font size. Don't count characters obsessively, but do put the important words first.

Get the sender name right first

The sender name is often what people check first, because it tells them whether this is someone they know. Use a name readers will recognise from when they signed up: your business, charity or club name, or your own name if you're a creator writing personally. "Priya at Hartley Garden Centre" can work well if one person writes the newsletter.

Keep it the same every time. Changing sender names confuses readers and can look suspicious to them. Avoid a "noreply" style address for the from address, too; replies are useful, and many people are put off by an address that refuses to listen.

What makes a subject line work

There's no formula, but subject lines that get opened by the right people usually do one or more of these things.

Be specific

"Spring update" could be anything. "Three new walks, and the hut opens on 6 April" tells a member exactly what's inside. Specific details such as dates, names, numbers you actually have and places signal that there's real content, not filler.

Lead with the reader's interest

Ask what the reader gets, not what you want to announce. "Our new website is live" is about you. "You can now book classes online" is about them.

Be clear before clever

Puns and teasers can work when your readers already trust you and enjoy your tone. On their own, they often hide what the email is about. If you want a playful subject, let the preheader do the explaining.

Match the content

The subject line is a promise. If it says "last chance", it should be the last chance. Misleading subjects might get one open, but they teach readers to distrust you, and disappointed readers are more likely to unsubscribe or complain. Spam complaints damage your deliverability for every future send.

Keep the style consistent

Some newsletters use a fixed pattern, such as "Reserve Notes: March" followed by the main story. That can help regular readers spot you, but on its own it gives little reason to open. A good compromise is a consistent prefix and a specific topic: "Reserve Notes: otters are back on the river".

Examples: before and after

VagueClearerWhy it's better
Newsletter #14Pre-order your Christmas cake by 1 DecemberSpecific action and deadline
Exciting news!We're opening on Sundays from JuneSays what the news actually is
An update from the teamYour donations funded 40 new nest boxesShows the reader's impact (use only real figures)
Don't miss out!!!Two places left on Saturday's pottery classConcrete, honest urgency
Season infoFixtures, kit and fees for the new seasonLists what's inside

What to avoid

  • All capitals, strings of exclamation marks and lots of symbols. They look like shouting and resemble the spam people have learned to ignore.
  • Fake replies and forwards. Starting with "Re:" or "Fwd:" when it isn't one is deceptive, and readers notice.
  • False urgency. Countdown language for something that isn't ending wears out quickly.
  • Overuse of emoji. One relevant emoji can add personality for some audiences. Several can look cluttered, and they display differently across devices. Screen readers also read emoji out by name, which can be clumsy.
  • Personalisation that might break. "Hi {first_name}" is fine when you have the data, but test what happens when the field is empty. A subject reading "Hi , your offer" looks careless. Most tools let you set a fallback such as "there".

Make the preheader work

If you don't set a preheader, the email app takes whatever text appears first in your email. That's often "View this email in your browser", alt text from a logo, or a menu of links. All of those waste the space.

Use the preheader to extend the subject line, not repeat it. Think of the two as a headline and a subheading:

Ashgrove Running ClubClub championship results are inPlus a new Thursday beginners' group and the summer social date.
Mel Okafor IllustrationThe new print is readyA limited run of the harbour series opens to subscribers on Friday at 10am.

How to set it

  1. Look for a "preview text" or "preheader" field in your email software, usually next to the subject line. Most mainstream tools have one.
  2. If there isn't one, make the first line of text in your email the preheader, and keep the "view in browser" link lower down.
  3. Write roughly 40 to 100 characters. Some apps show more and some less, so put the important part first.
  4. Preview it on your phone by sending a test to yourself before every campaign.

If you write your own HTML, the usual technique is a hidden block of text at the very top of the email body. The HTML email starter includes one with an explanation.

Testing subject lines

Many email tools offer A/B testing: they send two subject lines to small parts of your list, pick a winner, and send that to everyone else. It can be useful, with a few caveats:

  • Small lists give unreliable results. With a few hundred subscribers, the difference between two versions is often just chance. Treat results as hints, not proof.
  • Open rates are less reliable than they were. Apple Mail Privacy Protection, and image loading by some providers, mean many "opens" aren't real. If your tool can pick a winner by clicks instead, prefer that. See measuring results.
  • Test one thing at a time. Specific versus general, or question versus statement, so you learn something you can reuse.

Without A/B testing, keep a simple log: date, subject, preheader and clicks. Over a year you'll see which kinds of subject your readers respond to.

A quick checklist

  • The sender name is one readers will recognise, and it's the same as last time.
  • The key words of the subject are in the first 30 to 40 characters.
  • The subject is specific and honest about what's inside.
  • The preheader adds something the subject doesn't say.
  • Any personalisation has a sensible fallback.
  • You've seen the test email in your own inbox, on a phone.

For the full list of things to check before you press send, use our pre-send checklist.