E-Shot Media Practical guides to email newsletters

Grow

Growing a mailing list legally: forms, lead magnets, consent and records

Sign-up forms, lead magnets and double opt-in, plus what UK GDPR and PECR expect, including the soft opt-in and keeping proper records.

Updated 7 min read

A mailing list is only worth having if the people on it want to hear from you. That's partly common sense and partly law. In the UK, marketing emails are covered by two sets of rules: the UK GDPR, which governs how you handle personal data, and the Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulations (PECR), which have specific rules about sending electronic marketing.

This guide covers practical ways to grow a list, from sign-up forms to lead magnets, alongside what the rules expect. It's written for small organisations and is a plain-English summary, not legal advice. For anything you're unsure about, the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) guidance is the authority, and we link to it throughout.

Where sign-ups come from

Most small lists grow from a handful of places. You don't need all of them; pick the ones that match where your audience already meets you.

  • Your website: a short form on the home page, at the end of blog posts, and on a dedicated sign-up page you can link to from anywhere.
  • At the point of sale: a tick box at online checkout, or a QR code by the till pointing to the sign-up page.
  • Events: a tablet with the sign-up form, or paper forms that include the same wording as your online form.
  • Social media and booking forms: a profile link, or a separate, optional box to join.

Build a sign-up form that's clear and fair

A good form is short and honest. Ask only for what you'll use. For most newsletters, an email address is enough; a first name is optional and only useful if you'll personalise.

Example sign-up wording

Get Reserve Notes
One email a month about what's happening on the reserve, how donations are used, and ways to get involved. You can unsubscribe at any time using the link in every email. See our privacy notice for how we use your details.

[ Email address ] [ Sign me up ]

That wording tells people who you are, what they'll get, how often, and how to leave. If you'd also like to send something different, such as fundraising appeals or offers from a sister business, say so explicitly, or offer separate choices.

Lead magnets

A lead magnet is something useful offered in return for signing up: a printable guide, a discount code, a checklist, a seasonal planting calendar, or a free first lesson. They work well when the item is closely related to what the newsletter will contain. A gardening calendar attracts gardeners; a prize draw for a tablet attracts people who want a tablet.

Be clear that taking the lead magnet means joining the newsletter. Under the UK GDPR, consent should not be bundled up as a hidden condition. The fairest approach is to say plainly: "Get the free planting calendar and our monthly newsletter." If people can get the freebie without joining, you can expect a cleaner, more engaged list.

With double opt-in (sometimes called confirmed opt-in), someone who fills in your form receives an email asking them to click a link to confirm. They're only added once they click.

UK law doesn't require double opt-in. It is still worth considering, because it:

  • stops mistyped addresses and fake sign-ups getting onto your list;
  • prevents people signing others up without permission;
  • gives you good evidence that the owner of the address really asked to join;
  • tends to produce a more engaged list, which helps deliverability.

The trade-off is that some people never click the confirmation link, so your list grows a little more slowly. Keep the confirmation email short, with a clear subject such as "Please confirm your subscription to Reserve Notes", and tell people on the thank-you page to look for it, including in their spam folder.

When you rely on consent, the UK GDPR sets a high standard. Consent must be:

  • Freely given: people have a genuine choice, and saying no doesn't stop them buying from you or using your service.
  • Specific and informed: they know who you are and what they're agreeing to receive.
  • Unambiguous, by a clear positive action: ticking an unticked box, typing in their email to join, or clicking a sign-up button. Pre-ticked boxes, silence and inactivity don't count.
  • Separate: not hidden in terms and conditions or bundled with agreeing to something else.
  • Easy to withdraw: as easy as it was to give, with an unsubscribe link in every email that works.

The ICO’s guidance on direct marketing using electronic mail covers consent for marketing emails in more depth, and links on to its general consent guidance.

PECR: the email marketing rules

PECR adds rules specifically for electronic marketing. The key one for email is regulation 22. In summary, you must not send unsolicited marketing email to individuals unless they have specifically consented, or one of the soft opt-in exceptions applies.

"Marketing" is broad. It covers promoting products and services, but also promoting an organisation's aims and ideals, which includes a charity's fundraising appeals and a campaign group's calls to action. A purely factual message, such as a receipt or a notice that your opening hours have changed for a booked appointment, isn't usually marketing.

The products and services soft opt-in

The soft opt-in lets you email existing customers about similar things without separate consent, as long as all of these are true:

  1. You got their email address yourself, in the course of a sale or negotiations for a sale of a product or service (for example, they bought from you or asked for a quote).
  2. You're only marketing your own similar products or services.
  3. You gave them a simple chance to refuse marketing when you collected their details.
  4. You give them a simple way to opt out in every message you send.

It doesn't cover addresses bought from or shared by other organisations, and it doesn't let you market unrelated products, or other organisations' products, to those customers.

The charitable purposes soft opt-in

The Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 added a separate soft opt-in for charities, now in PECR regulation 22(3A). Broadly, it lets a charity send marketing about its charitable purposes to people who have expressed an interest in, or offered or given support to, those purposes, provided they were given a simple way to refuse when their details were collected and in every message. It has its own detailed conditions, and the ICO expects charities using both soft opt-ins to meet the conditions of each. Read the ICO's guidance before relying on it.

Individuals and corporate subscribers

PECR's consent rule applies to "individual subscribers". Emails to "corporate subscribers", such as a staff address at a limited company, don't need consent or a soft opt-in under PECR, although you must still say who you are and give a valid address for opt-outs. Sole traders and some partnerships count as individuals, so the stricter rules apply to them. And where a business address identifies a person, such as a named employee's address, the UK GDPR still applies to how you handle it.

Never buy or rent a list

Bought, rented or "scraped" lists are a bad idea on every front. The people on them haven't agreed to hear from you, so consent obtained by someone else is very unlikely to be specific enough to cover your emails, and the soft opt-in never applies to bought-in lists. They also tend to contain dead addresses and spam traps, which damage your sender reputation, and many email services forbid them in their terms.

The same goes for adding your email contacts or business cards from a networking event without asking. Invite them to sign up instead.

The UK GDPR expects you to be able to show that someone consented. For each subscriber, keep a record of:

  • Who consented: the email address, and name if collected.
  • When they consented: date and time.
  • How: which form, page, event or checkout, and whether they confirmed by double opt-in.
  • What they were told: the exact wording of the form and the privacy information at the time. Keep a copy whenever you change the wording.
  • Withdrawals: when they unsubscribed. Keep these on a suppression list so a later import never re-adds them, and treat a reply asking to be removed as an unsubscribe.

Most email software records the date, time and source of each sign-up automatically, and often the IP address too. Your job is mainly to keep copies of the form wording and to record sign-ups collected offline, such as paper forms at events. For soft opt-in contacts, record how and when you collected the address and that you offered the opt-out.

Putting it together

  1. Write your sign-up wording: who you are, what you'll send, how often, how to leave.
  2. Add a short form to your website and a link you can share anywhere.
  3. Decide whether to use double opt-in. For most small lists, it's worth it.
  4. Work out which existing contacts qualify for a soft opt-in, and which you need to ask.
  5. Save a copy of your form wording and privacy notice, with the date.
  6. Check your privacy notice explains how you use subscribers' details.

Once people are joining, welcome them properly. Our guide to welcome and re-engagement automations explains how. For terms used here, see the glossary.